USA Lacrosse All-American Honorable Mention
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2025 |
Bo Columbus |
| 2025 |
David Burr |
| 2026 |
Owen Tapper |
Inside Lacrosse All-American Honorable Mention
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2025 |
Bo Columbus |
USILA All-Americans Third Team
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2012 |
Kiel Matisz |
USILA All-Americans Honorable Mention
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2010 |
Trevor Moore |
| 2011 |
Trevor Moore |
| 2025 |
David Burr |
| 2026 |
Dylan Anderson |
| 2026 |
Owen Tapper |
USILA Scholar All-Americans
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2014 |
Sean Meagher |
| 2024 |
Elliot Holden |
| 2025 |
Bo Columbus |
USILA Team Academic Award
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2025 |
RMU |
USILA Senior North/South Game
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2008 |
Andrew Watt |
| 2012 |
Casey Abbott |
| 2012 |
Kyle Buchanan |
| 2012 |
Kiel Matisz |
Tewaaraton Award Semifinalists
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2012 |
Kiel Matisz |
Academic All-District (CoSIDA/CSC)
| Season |
Recipient |
| 2012 |
Kiel Matisz (First Team) |
| 2024 |
Elliot Holden |
| 2025 |
Nate Fechter |
