| Kevin Brownell2008-12 |
 Buffalo Bandits (2013-22) NLL NY Riptide (2022-23) NLL |
| Zach Bryant2015-18 |
 San Diego Seals (2019) NLL Ohio Machine (2018) MLL |
| Kyle Buchanan2009-12 |
Buffalo Bandits (2021-Present) NLL Connecticut Hammerheads (2020) MLL San Diego Seals (2019-20) NLL New England Black Wolves (2015-18) NLL Philadelphia Wings (2014) NLL Washington Stealth (2013) NLL |
| Zac Christianson2015-18 |
 Vancouver Warriors (2019) NLL |
| Bo Columbus2023-25 |
Philadelphia Wings (2025-26) NLL |
| Tyler Digby2010-13 |
 Colorado Mammoth (2020-22) NLL New York Riptide (2020) NLL New England Black Wolves (2019) NLL Calgary Roughnecks (2016-18) NLL Vancouver Stealth (2014-15) NLL |
| Mike Fleming2005-08 |
 Toronto Rock (2009) NLL |
| Tyson Gibson2016-19 |
Colorado Mammoth (2022-23) NLL New York Riptide (2020-22) NLL Philadelphia Barrage (2020) MLL |
| Jeff Gilbert2005 |
Toronto Rock (2009-11, 15-17) NLL Minnesota Swarm (2012-14) NLL |
| Jake Hayes2010-13 |
Calgary Roughnecks (2014) NLL |
| Corson Kealey- |
 Oshawa FireWolves (2025-present) NLL New York Riptide (2023-24) NLL Oshawa FireWolves (2022-23) NLL |
| JonPatrik Kealey2014-16 |
Buffalo Bandits (2020) NLL Rochester Knighthawks (2020) NLL New England Black Wolves (2018-19) NLL |
| Luke Laszkiewicz2013-16 |
Rochester Knighthawks (2017-18) NLL |
| Will MacLeod2023-25 |
 Halifax Thunderbirds (2025-26) NLL |
| Luc Magnan2012-15 |
 Ottawa Black Bears (2024-Present) NLL Halifax Thunderbirds (2019-24) NLL Rochester Knighthawks (2016-19) NLL Toronto Rock (2016) NLL |
| Kiel Matisz2009-12 |
Buffalo Bandits (2024-Present) NLL Vancouver Warriors (2024-25) NLL New York Riptide (2023-24) NLL Philadelphia Wings (2018-2023) NLL Ohio Machine (2012-15) MLL |
| Brad McCulley2017-20 |
Rochester Knighthawks (2025-present) NLL Vancouver Warriors (2023-24) NLL Buffalo Bandits (2021-24) NLL |
| Sean Meagher2011-14 |
 Florida Launch (2017-18) MLL Ohio Machine (2016-17) MLL Charlotte Hounds (2015) MLL |
| Kean Moon2022-25 |
 Georgia Swarm (2025-present) NLL |
| Trevor Moore2008-11 |
Vancouver Stealth (2012) NLL Chesapeake Bayhawks (2011) MLL |
| Kevin Neufeld2010-13 |
Vancouver Stealth (2014) NLL |
| James Rahe2013-16 |
Vancouver Warriors/Stealth (2017-20) NLL |
| Justin Robinson2018-19 |
Buffalo Bandits (2021-24) NLL Saskatchewan Rush (2019-20) NLL |
| Jacob Ruest2012-15 |
Oshawa FireWolves (2024-25) NLL Las Vegas Desert Dogs (2023-24) NLL Albany FireWolves (2022) NLL Colorado Mammoth (2017-20) NLL |
| Jordon Sealock2007-10 |
Philadelphia Wings (2012) NLL Calgary Roughnecks (2011) NLL |
| Michael Seidel2012-15 |
Georgia Swarm (2016) NLL |
| Brian Simmons2022-25 |
Colorado Mammoth (2025-present) NLL |
| Patrick Smith2007-11 |
Ohio Machine (2012) MLL |
| Ryan Smith2017-21 |
Rochester Knighthawks (2021-present) NLL Chaos Lacrosse Club (2021-present) PLL |
| Corbyn Tao-Brambleby2008-11 |
Colorado Mammoth (2016) NLL Minnesota Swarm (2012-15) NLL |
| Andrew Watt2005-08 |
Buffalo Bandits (2014-17) NLL Minnesota Swarm (2009-13) NLL |
| Mitch Wilde2010-13 |
Halifax Thunderbirds (2024-25) NLL Calgary Roughnecks (2017-23) NLL Buffalo Bandits (2014-16) NLL |
